Land reform is probably one of the most difficult domestic policy issues to be dealt with by zimbabwe, namibia, south africa and australia. The government of zimbabwe has demonstrated a commitment to an equitable, legal, and transparent land reform program consistent with agreements reached at the international donors conference on land reform and resettlement in zimbabwe held in harare, zimbabwe, in september 1998. Disparity between policy design and implementation medicine masiiwa institute of development studies university of zimbabwe may 2004 note. Moyo, the interaction of market and compulsory land acquisition processes with social action in zimbabwe s land reform, p.
The concept of land reform has varied over time according to the range of functions which land itself has. Economic benefits and costs of land redistribution in zimbabwe in. This declaration was also a clear and very public admittance that land reform had failed. The five year programme was premised on orthodox reform packages prescribed by the imf, including. A comparative analysis of the politics of land reform in zimbabwe and south africa, ibid.
It focused on the implementation of the land reform programme and whether women benefitted economically from the initiative. Experts agree that land reforms in japan, korea, and taiwan, have made a major contribution to overcoming the legacy of colonial development king, 1973. A mere reference to land reforms in zimbabwe raised eyebrows. This culminated in hyperinflation, starting in february 2007, and the economic. It has led to zimbabwe s economic and social collapse. Macleans mzumara, department of economics, bindura university of science education. An analysis of the impact of land redistribution projects. The relationship between agriculture and land reform many critics of land reform base their arguments on the need to sustain agricultural production and the belief that land reform involves too radical an alteration of the production structure for output to be maintained. Senators bill frist rtennessee and russ feingold dwisconsin introduced the bill on march 8, 2001. Much of this land was previously cattle ranches, with limited. Land reform in zimbabwe officially began in 1980 with the signing of the lancaster house agreement, as an effort to more equitably distribute land between black subsistence farmers and white zimbabweans of european ancestry, who had traditionally enjoyed superior political and economic status. This study explored how the land reform in zimbabwe empowered women economically through sustainable livelihoods initiatives. A study on the impact of governance on land reform in. In this section, we zero in on masvingo province in the central south and east of the country.
In colombia, implementation of market assisted land reform has been shown to have a potential of targeting the most unproductive areas, thus leading to considerable productivity increases machado et al. Land reforms refer to the transfer of land ownership from a relatively small number of wealthy owners to landless peasants. Land reform is a zimbabwe success story it will be the. Speeding up the identification for compulsory acquisition of not less than. To bolster a struggling economy, president mnangagwa is launching a new programme to address the socio economic consequences of robert mugabes land reform programme in the early 2000s. Evidence on the performance of zimbabwes early land reform effort is mixed. Ruswa masters minithesis, institute for social development, university of the western cape.
Benefits and costs of land reform in zimbabwe with implications for southern africa, klaus deininger, hans hoogeveen and bill kinsey. Economic isolation is hindering zimbabwes transformation lifting sanctions and increasing international investment will speed land and security sector reform. World media demonised zimbabwe and the fasttrack land reforms which were initiated in 1999. That can include governmentinitiated property redistribution, transfer of ownership and the rights of the land. The destabilization of its agricultural sector, has resulted in food insecurity, unemployment currently at over 70%, inflation as of april 2004 at over 584%, and. Land reform in zimbabwe has radically transformed the rural economy. There is widespread agreement on the need for land reform in zimbabwe as a means of reducing poverty. One obvious result of increased and uncontrolled urban youth unemployment is a blurred future for the nation. Nevertheless, it was the policy of the incoming government of the african national congress anc to effect land reform that would to a significant. A study on the impact of governance on land reform in zimbabwe.
There is also a struggle within the zimbabwean government over the issue which. The arguments in favor of economic land reform presented above are also consistent with the economic theory which states that a onetime egalitarian distribution of assets in an environment of imperfect markets is associated with permanent higher levels of growth deininger et al. These economic events have been predominantly driven by the political economy of zimbabwe. A quantitative analysis of zimbabwes land reform policy core. In 2016, then zimbabwean president robert mugabe declared a state of disaster for agriculture, a declaration which allowed international donors to help. This in effect was the beginning of zimbabwe s land problem. The negative impacts of land reform on the status of large carnivores documented here could be reduced by modifying the way in which land reform programmes are implemented. The land reform programme was described as illegal and a failure. Pdf the research analysed the impacts of land reform programme on politico economic development in zimbabwe using the case of.
Thus the impact of droughts and the ongoing economic recession has. Research work on the performance of zimbabwes land reforms, more so the extent to which the. In this paper we use a unique micro data set with information on land. The land reform programme in zimbabwe has been a major area of international discussion for almost five years now. Zimbabwe democracy and economic recovery act of 2001. But despite the general consensus not to repeat zimbabwe s economic disaster, few people disagree that land ownership needs to be reformed in south africa. Evaluate the failures and or successes of land tenure reform in zimbabwe. As discussed in section 4, the political environment has been dominated by political goals taking.
Land reform, commercial agriculture and local economic growth. Did 300,000 families benefit from zimbabwe s post1999 land reforms. The land reform in zimbabwe was organised in line with that slogan and had the following basic elements of speed, which made it to be known as the fast track land reform. What were the effects of the land reform program in zimbabwe. A total of 712 of these claims, for 292 995 hectares, were settled between 2009 and december 2011, against a target of 1 845 claims for the period. Research was conducted in makoni district of manicaland province, zimbabwe. The paper argues that economic structural adjustment programs esaps, introduced by the world bank and the international monetary fund as major international financial institutions in economic globalization, have been an inappropriate public policy for zimbabwe. Fast track land reform in zimbabwe centre for public. A lot has been written articulating the reasons which led to the imposition of sanctions and their effects. While land reform is a significant and legitimate concern for many people in zimbabwe, particularly those eking out a living on overpopulated and depleted communal lands, the government of zimbabwe s decision to launch the fasttrack land reform programme was prompted not by a desire to realize human rights but by a desire to maintain power. Published by friedrich ebert stiftung and institute of development studies, university of zimbabwe, harare, 2004.
Jan 14, 2016 the negative impacts of land reform on the status of large carnivores documented here could be reduced by modifying the way in which land reform programmes are implemented. Redistributive land reform and poverty reduction in zimbabwe. The invasion of the largely whiteowned farms, accompanied by violent evictions and wholesale and wanton destruction and looting in 2000, led to a crisis between the judiciary and the executive that resulted in most of the judiciary being forced out of office. An economic analysis of the impact of land acquisition on agricultural.
The zimbabwe democracy and economic recovery act s. Firstly, the model of land reform that was applied under zimbabwes ftlrp considered agricultural models at the expense of a wildlifebased model. Zimbabwe programme for economic and social transformation zimprest and it was. In july 1990 the government released an economic policy statement, zimbabwe a framework for economic reform 19911995, in which it announced a major policy shift from stateled economic development towards a market based approach. According to the reserve bank of zimbabwe rbz 2005, the high unemployment rate will lead to an increase in crime rate especially in urban areas. This early land reform produced a rather feudal form of politics based on racial and class discrimination imposed on the african population by the british government and white rhodesians. An adapted version of this paper appears in the edited collection post independence land reform in zimbabwe, published in may 2004 by the friedrich ebert stiftung in harare. Zimbabwe is saddled with two million percent annual price increases, rampant corruption and pervasive unemployment. Gdp growth has dropped well below 2 percent, and the economy is half the size it was 15 years ago. Despite limited investment, argues wandile sihlobo, the zimbabwean governments approach is critical for building credibility in its reform agenda at home. Oct 03, 2002 johannesburg, 3 october irin zimbabwe s fasttrack land reform programme has ignored the critical role played by the commercial farming sector in the economy, analysts and farmers have warned. Land reform in zimbabwe has been highly controversial.
The unprecedented social, political and economic crisis facing zimbabwe was largely precipitated by the government of zimbabwe sgoz seizure of commercial farms in 2000 under the guise of land reform. Since 1997 shifts in zimbabwe s land reform, agricultur al and economic policies, and its relations with the international community, including external financial institutions, have accompanied. The land distribution in zimbabwe after colonization was well inclined to the white settlers and the black majorities were driven to stay in reserves, that were meant to disempower people and unfortunately these areas were infertile and this was part. Land reform, a purposive change in the way in which agricultural land is held or owned, the methods of cultivation that are employed, or the relation of agriculture to the rest of the economy. Since 1997 shifts in zimbabwes land reform, agricultur al and economic policies, and its relations with the international community, including external financial institutions, have accompanied.
A critical analysis of the land reform programme in zimbabwe. Zimbabwe, on one side of the spectrum, is facing a crisis in democratisation due to its radical approach to land reform. Evidence on the impact of land reform in zimbabwe a panel survey of resettlement households started in 1983 shows clearly. The social, political and economic transformative impact of the fast track land reform programme on the lives of women farmers in goromonzi and vungugweru districts of zimbabwe page 1 table of contents list of tables, figures and boxes ii introduction 1 1. These counterarguments against the kinseytype criticisms of the financial and macroeconomic implications of sustained land reform all came to figure prominent. Nov 15, 2017 how mugabes land reform crippled the economy zimbabwe was once the bread basket of africa. My central argument in this minithesis is that land reform in zimbabwe was not a resounding success because of the. Pdf prior to 2000 zimbabwe was hailed as a conservation success story. This paper looks at the historical processes that influence the indigenisation and economic empowerment programme ieep adopted by the government of zimbabwe goz and identifies the potential trickledown benefits, constraints and alternative. Land reform is a zimbabwe success story it will be the basis for economic recovery under mnangagwa november 29, 2017 9. After 2000, around 145,000 families were allocated smallholder plots and a further 20,000 took on medium scale farms. These mixed results with regards to the impact of land reforms on productivity.
An evaluation of indigenisation policy in zimbabwe by busisiwe monica shumba 210505399 a dissertation submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of master of social science in the school of social sciences at the university of kwazulunatal november 2014 supervisor. The impact of land reform on the status of large carnivores. Past research has concluded that the economic decline of zimbabwe has mainly been caused by poor monetary policies and failure of fiscal policies to control the budget deficit. The zimbabwe farmers union believes the land reform will have a positive impact on. In addition to aggregate evidence on the positive poverty impact. Overall impacts of fast track land reform programme. This had well known socioeconomic impacts, but to date little research.
In recent years, there has been considerable economic hardship in zimbabwe. Many western countries argue that the government of zimbabwe s land reform program, recurrent interference with, and intimidation of the judiciary, as well as maintenance of unrealistic price controls and exchange rates has led to a sharp drop in investor confidence. The major challenge for the current land policy is to improve the credibility and efficacy of the governments approach to land reform. This replaced an agrarian structure that was divided between 4,500 largescale commercial farms and many small communal area farms. This research aimed to closely examine some of these policies that the zimbabwean government implemented, the effects of these policies on economic activity, employment and.
Unemployment and implications to social and political. Introduction at independence in 1980 zimbabwe inherited a highly skewed pattern of land distribution. This papers assesses the overall impacts of the governments fast track land reform programme on the agricultural sector. Land reform accelerated economic decline exponentially, with real gdp plunging 45 per cent in the decade to 2009. Nov 29, 2017 land reform is a zimbabwe success story it will be the basis for economic recovery under mnangagwa november 29, 2017 9. Land reform and agricultural production in zimbabwe gupea.
Postindependence land reform in zimbabwe controversies and impact on the economy edited by medicine masiiwa. Where zimbabwe got it wrong lessons for south africa. This paper assesses the potential consequences of a land reform scheme that draws on proposals. How land reform can contribute to economic growth and. How land reform can contribute to economic growth and poverty. Unequal benefits from esap reforms, especially from new land uses. The impact of economic structural adjustment programs esaps.
Reforms such as these may be proclaimed by a government, by interested groups, or by revolution. The effects of urban youth unemployment in zimbabwe. Johannesburg, 3 october irin zimbabwe s fasttrack land reform programme has ignored the critical role played by the commercial farming sector in the economy. An economic reform initiative in zimbabwe has been long overdue. The effect of zimbabwe s failed land reform programme is clear. The programmes stated targets were intended to alter the ethnic balance of land ownership. Various authors have argued for the integration of land reform with wider developmental activities.
Pdf overall impacts of fast track land reform programme. Land, identity, and power global crisis solutions page 2 summary zimbabwe is currently facing numerous socioeconomic crises. The zimbabwean experience the use of economic sanctions to force an opponent to abide by the law is not a new phenomenon in documented history. Experts believe that an effort to reform the countrys political corruption and irresponsible monetary policies will be central to establishing social and economic stability in the long run. The land reform programme can achieve its desired social, economic and political objectives if the redistribution exercise is planned properly. Firstly, the model of land reform that was applied under zimbabwe s ftlrp considered agricultural models at the expense of a wildlifebased model. Background to the research 2 land reform in zimbabwe 3. Land reform in zimbabwe free international relations and. Pdf the impact of land reform in zimbabwe on the conservation of. In each of these countries the process of land reform is incomplete. Zimbabwe, land reform and white compensation africa at lse. Land reform under structural adjustment in zimbabwe. Economic isolation is hindering zimbabwes transformation.
439 912 547 847 929 35 632 120 374 790 805 1009 943 1220 559 1385 1337 805 1151 1010 1018 502 73 466 1404 1015 469 578 378 1086 1024